Homebutler logoSign Up
Sump Pump Not Working? How to Troubleshoot It Before the Next Storm

Sump Pump Not Working? How to Troubleshoot It Before the Next Storm

Published November 16, 2026

A sump pump only matters during the worst storm of the year, which is exactly when you find out it isn't working. A five-minute test before the rainy season can save you a flooded basement.

Quick Answer

First check that the pump has power: it's plugged in, the GFCI outlet hasn't tripped, and the breaker is on. Then test it by pouring a bucket of water into the pit until the float rises. If the pump doesn't start, the float may be stuck or the switch has failed. If it runs but doesn't remove water, check for a clogged intake, a frozen or blocked discharge line, or a failed check valve. Sump pumps typically last 7–10 years.

How to Test Your Sump Pump

  1. Pour a bucket of water slowly into the sump pit.
  2. The float should rise and turn the pump on.
  3. The water level should drop quickly, and the pump should shut off on its own.
  4. Go outside and confirm water is coming out of the discharge line.

Test it at least once a year, and before your area's rainy season.

Common Problems and Fixes

SymptomLikely causeFix
Pump doesn't run at allNo power, tripped GFCI, or breakerRestore power; plug directly into the outlet, not an extension cord
Pump doesn't start when water risesFloat stuck against the pit wall or debrisReposition the pump and clear debris
Motor hums but no water movesClogged intake or jammed impellerUnplug, clean the intake screen and impeller
Runs constantlyStuck switch, high water table, or failed check valveCheck the switch and valve; may need a larger pump
Turns on and off rapidlyFailed check valve letting water flow backReplace the check valve
Runs but pit stays fullFrozen or blocked discharge line, or pump worn outClear the line; replace the pump if it's old

Protect Yourself With a Backup

Sump pumps tend to fail during storms, which is also when power goes out. A battery backup pump or a water-powered backup (where allowed by local code) keeps water moving during an outage. A water alarm in the pit is a cheap early warning.

Check Your Insurance

Standard homeowners policies often exclude water that backs up through drains or overflows from a sump pump. Coverage usually requires a water backup endorsement, which is typically inexpensive to add. Check your policy before you need it.

What It Costs

Replacing a standard sump pump with a plumber typically costs several hundred to around $1,500 depending on the pump, access, and plumbing changes. Battery backup systems add to that. A float switch or check valve replacement costs less.

Get It Triaged and Find a Plumber

Describe what's happening in HomeButler and it sorts the problem into urgent or routine, tells you what to check first, and shows rated plumbers near you so you can compare options and request quotes. When the job is done, the repair is logged to your home's history automatically.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does a sump pump last? Typically 7–10 years, less if it cycles constantly.

Should a sump pump run all the time? No. Constant running usually means a stuck float switch, a failed check valve, a high water table, or an undersized pump.

Can I replace a sump pump myself? Many homeowners can, if the new pump matches the existing discharge size and the outlet is GFCI protected. Hire a plumber if the discharge line or check valve needs rework.

What should I do if my basement is flooding right now? Stay out of standing water if outlets or appliances are submerged and turn off power to the area only if you can do it safely. Call a plumber or water mitigation company, and document the damage for insurance.

Sign up free